How to Help Retirement Plan Participants Make Optimal Financial Decisions
Executive Summary
Employees face a series of complex, interdependent financial decisions across their lifetimes — contributing to a retirement plan, allocating assets, managing risk, choosing sources of advice, planning for retirement income, and deciding how and when to draw down assets.
Using a large, nationally representative survey sample, this paper examines how advice seeking, plan use, investment behaviors, technology adoption, and pension expectations differ between public and private sector employees. The goal is to identify where plan providers and employers can intervene most effectively to help their employees make optimal lifetime financial decisions.
The analysis integrates descriptive evidence with multivariate regression models to isolate drivers of advice use, saving behavior, investment confidence, and AI/robo-adoption. Findings highlight clear opportunities: targeted human advice channels for public employees, better plan design and defaults, simplified investment menus, stronger employer contributions for defined contribution (DC) retirement plans, and guidance that integrates defined benefit (DB) and DC decisions.
Key Findings
Increase access to professional financial advice for public workers.¹ Our analysis demonstrates that public workers are significantly less likely to work with a financial advisor than private workers and are significantly less likely to be interested in working with a digital/robo solution. Public sector employers can potentially help close this gap by providing access to human financial advisors.
Nudge public sector workers to save more. Public sector workers are saving less for retirement in defined contribution plans. One likely driver of lower savings rates among public sector participants is the fact that they are less likely to be offered a match or other employer contribution. Adding some kind of match, especially one stretched to target higher savings rates, is one potential solution.
Public sector workers need an “easy button” for investing. Public sector workers are less likely to be comfortable building their own portfolios and also less likely to know how their DC balances are allocated. Public sector workers are also more likely to rate the process of making investment decisions to be more difficult.
Complex core menus can be a barrier to savings. Public sector workers who say their DC core menu has too many choices save significantly less than those who describe the core menu size as adequate or even having too few choices.
Improve retirement outcomes with goal-based, income-focused guidance. Public sector participants are more likely to indicate that they do not know their preferred drawdown strategy and are more likely to cite interest in working with a financial advisor in retirement. Providers should therefore consider moving beyond generic withdrawal education and deliver integrated retirement-income planning tools that combine all the sources of income and wealth that workers are using to fund retirement.
¹ Providers and public sector employees should also review and understand the fees and expenses related to utilizing a financial advisor and AI/robo advisor before engaging.
About The Contributor(s)
Subscribe Today
Lorem ipsum odor amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Pellentesque egestas praesent vehicula odio, sem id quam. Conubia parturient tempor rhoncus rhoncus vel? Quisque senectus sem odio nibh sollicitudin porttitor. Aptent leo erat risus dignissim lobortis finibus interdum placerat. Laoreet lobortis sollicitudin praesent vivamus duis nibh euismod. Feugiat facilisis ipsum dis commodo fames potenti neque nunc. Gravida laoreet libero; imperdiet vivamus efficitur facilisi.